America should do more!
Posted by عمار - aMmAr | Posted in Pakistan, Politics, Social and Politics, islam | Posted on 10-02-2010-05-2008
7

I belong to that Pakistani generation who grew up embracing American culture. From John Bon Jovi to Steve Jobs; my generation listens to American music, watches American cinema and idolize American entrepreneurs and inventors. Even the two Governments have a lot of history to share. Our rulers in uniform or civil attire follow an unspoken pledge where they always keep American interest before their own country’s interest. But I always wonder how things are the other way around? Do American’s fancy our culture or respect Pakistani religious and social values?
These are the questions that every Pakistani inquires about since 9/11: an incident that didn’t involve any Pakistani but after a decade every Pakistani is paying its price. Today an average American might feel secure but an average Pakistani feels anything but secure. I don’t agree with the stance, that terrorism in the name of religion never existed in Pakistan before September 11 incident. Before 9/11 only the minority sects (Shiites in particular) were the victims of such atrocities and now terrorism has gone main stream.
The Bush-Musharraf “Do More” policy is in continuation under Obama – Zardari joint venture. The drone attacks kill more innocent than terrorists, Black Water is no longer referred to the rain aftermath on the streets of Karachi. But one can witness bits and pieces of the “CHANGE” Obama once promised during his election campaign. Those who saw Hillary Clinton’s interaction with the Pakistani main stream journalists do remember how the present secretary of state; was bombarded with pointing questions from all side. In that TV interaction she stressed on bridging gaps and structuring new relationships. The recent visit of Ms. Farah A. Pandith (U.S. Special Representative to Muslim Communities) appears to be an attempt in that context.

Recently I along with some colleagues from the blogging community was invited by U.S. Consulate General, Karachi to meet Ms. Pundit in a dinner meeting. She appeared quite enthusiastic on her new task and talked about plans that will help rebuilding people to people association between the two countries. She emphasized on looking at the future that might bring some difference in the perception of an average Pakistani about American policies in the region. But I personally believe that these plans are very far fetched, as a lot of practical work needs to be done on ground to improve the security situation in Pakistan and create a working relationship of mutual interest and respect. We do welcome any effort that promises to bring positive change but till than America needs to do more!
Popularity: 41% [?]

[...] This cup of tea was served by: R O N I N [...]
Nice round up of the event,along with the background. I do agree that things have changed over the years.
Definitely agree with you on the ‘America should do well’
Think you’ve put it simple and straight up, a balanced piece.
Having said that I do think you should mention your question and the answer she gave you. You were there representing the Blogosphere and so it would be great for people to read Farha’s opinion on how bloggers can help in building relationships.
What a strikingly straightforward thinking!! We and America need more of it:)
@Sana: Thanks for the comment and the suggestion, I do represent the local blogging community where ever I go. But my piece is more contextual to the situation between the two countries.
@Rumaisa: Welcome to RONIN and I am glad you agree with my point of view here
America should do more? Yes but while it changes parts of its aggresive attitutes. The problem is us in the mideast went through so much up to now due to wrong policy of the US.It seems they’re not going to change their way and really “change”.
Any country that does not surrender to their evil requests, they punish them by sanctions or they try to change the governments by coup or velvet revolution (as they did in pakistan previously, in Ukraine, in Latin America etc)
The other way of occupation is enforcing their materialistic culture to destroy culture of other nations. While americans themselves the least know about lifestyle in different countries.
Agree with your analysis of the situation- thanks for sharing the experience!
@Shahrzad: Cant deny any of the aspects you mentioned in your comment!
@Specs: I am glad you found the post useful and you’re welcome!